Challenging Discrimination and Legacy Admissions: My Journey to Equality in Higher Education

Justin Samuels
2 min readSep 2, 2023

Introduction

My journey to fight for equality in higher education began with a lawsuit against Barnard College for sex discrimination, not only for gay males but also straight ones. Along the way, I filed complaints with the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) against seven Ivy League institutions and numerous private colleges, all of which employed legacy admissions policies. The OCR’s ongoing investigation into Harvard University for its handling of legacy applicants has set a crucial precedent for the battle against discriminatory practices in higher education.

A Quest for Equal Treatment

My determination to challenge discrimination in higher education emerged when I recognized the pervasive issue of sex discrimination at Barnard College. I firmly believed that discrimination based on gender or sexual orientation had no place in modern education. This initial lawsuit laid the foundation for my broader efforts to promote equality and fairness in the academic world.

Legacy Admissions: An Unfair Advantage

As I delved deeper into the landscape of higher education, I became increasingly aware of legacy admissions, a practice that appeared to grant a distinct advantage to students with family ties to an institution. Legacy admissions favored the privileged few, and it was apparent that this practice had the potential to perpetuate inequality within the educational system.

The Role of the Office for Civil Rights

In my pursuit of equality, I turned to the OCR, a vital agency tasked with ensuring compliance with civil rights laws in education. The OCR’s investigation into Harvard University for its legacy admissions practices marked a significant turning point in the fight for fairness. This investigation not only spotlighted the issue but also set a precedent that could influence the policies of other elite institutions across the nation.

Filing Complaints: A Call for Change

Inspired by the OCR’s actions and determined to bring about change, I filed complaints against seven Ivy League institutions and numerous private colleges, all of which maintained legacy admissions policies. My goal was clear: to challenge these policies, which I believed had the potential to perpetuate inequality in college admissions.

Conclusion

My journey to fight for equality in higher education began with a lawsuit against Barnard College for sex discrimination and expanded to encompass a broader challenge against legacy admissions policies. With the OCR’s ongoing investigation into Harvard University, we stand on the precipice of change. The battle for equal treatment in education continues, and I am committed to pushing for fairness, diversity, and equal opportunity for all students, regardless of their background or familial connections. The fight is far from over, but together, we can shape a future where every individual has a fair chance to pursue their educational dreams.

--

--